Debate continues over Palm Beach light rail

DINA GETOVA

Palm Beach residents are continuing to speak out against the fourth stage of the Gold Coast light rail project, which would extend the track to the Gold Coast Airport.

Gold Coast light rail

Palm Beach residents are concerned with the affect the light rail extension could have on the natural environment and on the Gold Coast Highway. Photo: Dina Getova

Palm Beach local Karen Rowles has been campaigning against any further extensions to the existing light rail track for five years, and is concerned about any planned route that would take the light rail through Palm Beach.

Ms Rowles said she believed extending the light rail through Palm Beach would result in “high-density high rises” being built “all through Palm Beach, as far back as the M1”.

Ms Rowles, who has previously campaigned against high-density development in the area after a high-rise was built right next to her home, said she believed the light rail would add to overdevelopment in the area.

She has started a petition against the light rail, which has so far been signed by 13,322 people.

The existing light rail track runs from Helensvale to Broadbeach, and Stage 3 of the project, which has been planned but not yet constructed, will extend the line from Broadbeach to Burleigh Heads.

Stage 4 of the project will extend the track from Burleigh Heads through to the Gold Coast Airport in Coolangatta.

The original Stage 4 plan was for the light rail to travel through Palm Beach along the Gold Coast Highway, but the new proposal is to turn off on 19th Avenue and then avoid the Highway.

Despite resident concerns, the project looks set to go ahead after the Queensland Government and the City of Gold Coast made a pledge last week to start the business case for the light rail link, which will be funded under a 50/50 partnership between the State and Council.

Gold Coast light rail

Both the City of Gold Coast council and the Queensland Government believe the light rail extension is important for the city’s development. Photo: Dina Getova

 

Premier Annastacia Palaszczuk said in a statement that the deal was important for Queensland.

“This business case will support the next critical steps needed to push major transport investments on the Gold Coast forward which is vital for Queensland’s economic recovery,” the Premier said.

“This is about building a pipeline of projects that can continue to support and create jobs, boost our economy and improve transport for locals, particularly those living on the southern end of the Gold Coast.”

Gold Coast Mayor Tom Tate also defended the project and said the light rail extension was important for the area.

“Stage 4 will result in a 40km public transport spine linking key employment, transport, health and education nodes,” Cr Tate said.

“This southern link is of strategic importance to the Gold Coast, Queensland and New South Wales,” he said.

“It is so much more than a transport project.”

But Karen Rowles isn’t the only local who is opposed to the light rail extension.

Local council volunteer and Palm Beach Promotions Committee member Shannon May has also spoken out against the project.

Ms May, who also runs social media accounts for Palm Beach Gold Coast Community and Palm Beach Club 4221, said she believed the light rail would be “detrimental” to the already overcrowded Gold Coast Highway, as well as causing damage to the natural environment.

“To come through Palm Beach, it will need to go through our Burleigh National Park and kill many species, including our already endangered koalas,” Ms May said.

“We do not want the tram to cut up our beachside suburbs,” she said.

“There is nothing good that can come of this.”

Ms May said it was important to “represent the locals” when planning the light rail.

“As a local, I can tell you that the majority of people do not want the light rail coming through [Palm Beach],” she said.

“Nor do Burleigh residents for that matter.”

Stage 4 Gold Coast light rail extension map

Stage 4 of the light rail extension would extend the track from Burleigh Heads to the Gold Coast Airport. Photo: Courtesy Queensland Department of Transport and Main Roads

 

Division 13 Councillor Daphne McDonald said residents from both Palm Beach and Burleigh had voiced concerns to her about the light rail.

“Issues that have been raised with me… are the impact on residents and businesses where stations are located, loss of green space and reduced deep planting, and the loss of car parks and the impact on surrounding streets,” Cr McDonald said.

Cr McDonald said other concerns from residents included the noise of the light rail and the potential for the light rail to “bring in crime”.

Gold Coast Mayor Tom Tate said Council was aware of the objections to the light rail extension and was working with the community to plan the new extension.

“I know some people have expressed concern and I’m urging robust debate as we finalise the plan,” Cr Tate said.

“I’ll be front and centre of this consultation to ensure we get the best outcome for our city,” he said.

But Ms May is unconvinced and has her own ideas about where the light rail extension should run.

“In my opinion the light rail should go down West Burleigh Road and link up to Varsity Station,” she said.

Ms May said that route would benefit big businesses without hindering locals.

“It would support many businesses along the way, including Stocklands and Tree Tops Shopping Centres,” she said.

Ms Rowles, however, remains firm on her “no light rail” stance.

“I’m completely against the light rail coming south of Broadbeach,” she said.

“I don’t want Stage 3A or 4 to go ahead at all.”

You can read more about the proposed light rail route on the Queensland Transport and Main Roads website.

Comments

  1. I have lived ln palm beach for 40 years and I am excited to have the light rail come through to the airport
    High density living is the way way forward but the building themselves need to be more green sustainable and that we can set immediate agenda’s around now

    Like

  2. Sue Ralph says:

    I have to agree with Karen Rowles and Shannon May. The disruption to businesses during the prolonged construction will no doubt be the final straw to so many businesses in Palm Beach. Covid has brought many businesses to their knees and I am fearful construction of the light rail will be the end of most along the route….as it was for many in Broadbeach previously! We have buses going to the airport many times a day & mostly they are almost empty. If we must update our transport system surely it would be more sensible to have electric buses supplied by the local Burleigh Company Bustech? These buses are able to deviate from the route in times of accidents etc…they don’t require millions of dollars in ugly tracks and electrical lines, and we would be supporting a local business at a time when we desperately need jobs. There are hundreds of reasons NOT to have a light rail track destroying the souls of Burleigh and Palm Beach. Annastacia Palaszczuk you need to come to our town and have a decent look and talk to the people who are going to have to live with this awful waste of money and destruction of our village….PLEASE

    Like

  3. kerry riseley says:

    there is NO ROOM for the light rail through palm beach making this road 1lane each way is so pathetic anyone that thought of it has no idea this becomes cloged at the best of times with normal trafic traveling on 2lanes each way finish the light rail at burleigh heads the reason its going down the beach front is there is NO room through the centre of burleigh heads just like palm beach

    Like

  4. Maree Richardson says:

    I totally agree with Karen and Daphne. NO LIGHT RAIL THROUGH PALM BEACH.To noisy to ugly .traffic not enough parking.Will bring back CRIME to the area. And we don’t need it .We are not WINGERS we are concerned residents that love the place we live,and don,’t want it to be like Surfers or Broadbeach

    Like

  5. David Ungar says:

    Our existing excellent bus service can be expanded and the buses themselves changed to electric power. Burleigh local bus builder can supply them.
    There is no need for hugely expensive extra bridges, resumptions, tunnels, road levelling or any major construction to run the bus service over the planned Gold Coast highway route that the Mayor and Premier are advocating.
    Link the existing light rail to Robina or Varsity Heavy Rail. How can that be more expensive than a highway route?
    Extend the Heavy Rail from Varsity to the NSW border as planned next to the M1 and via the Gold Coast Airport.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: